Terms and Conditions: When A Cis Woman Dates A Trans Man
Maureenâs post about living a double life (queer by day, straight-assumed by night) and Sylvia Reneeâs question âhow have you navigated the minefield of interpersonal gender?â got me thinking about my own relationship with gender and the closet. Namely, Iâm not in the closet and donât want to be, but these days itâs oddly hard for me to avoid â not because I face bigoted parents or discrimination at work; nothing like that. The problem, such as it is, is that Iâm a cisgender girl dating a transgender boy.
Clearly my problem is a rather minor one, particularly compared to those my person and other transpeople face daily. But it does present an awkward situation I havenât yet untangled. It comes down to the intractable issue of Titles. What do we call each other? The paucity of terms is a problem lots of couples of all gender combinations face. An older unmarried straight couple I know lament that their options are limited to the sexless âpartnerâ and the geriatric âcompanion.â But for queer people it can feel like a choice between being in the closet or out.
The gender-neutral options look bleak. Even if âpartnerâ werenât too marital for my taste, it calls to mind lawyers and business partners. (Google-image âpartnerâ and youâll find a slew of stock images of suit-jacketed arms shaking hands.) âSpecial friendâ is too revolting to merit further discussion. âSignificant otherâ isnât the worst, but it doesnât really have a place outside advice columns. Itâs a little stilted for dropping into conversation: âOh, Iâm just having dinner with my significant other.â
Boyfriend and girlfriend would be simplest, of course, but neither of us is crazy about being a boyfriend or girlfriend, respectively. Weâre both committed to having a queer relationship; that is, one we make from scratch, considering our individual desires and needs, rather than what I think of as ticky-tacky relationships: they all look just the same.
BF and GF (especially GF) feel, as my person points out, prescriptive. Visions of Rory Gilmore dance in my head. And with all gender-specific terms (beau? lover boy? gentleman caller?) thereâs the invisibility problem. I casually mention my boyfriend and suddenly Iâm straight. Is that so terrible? Well, it makes me feel like Iâm hiding my queerness â like Iâm retreating into the closet. Even someone who meets me in a queer context might well assume from that word that Iâm in a straight relationship. The people I meet in the rest of my life almost certainly will. âBoyfriendâ and its ilk also elide part of his identity. He wants people to respect his gender (by using the right pronouns and so forth), but his ultimate goal isnât for everyone to think heâs a cis boy. For many of the same reasons I want to be recognized as queer, to know that my identity and experiences arenât buried beneath a heap of assumptions, he usually wants to be recognized as genderqueer. But it feels absurdâand absurdly insistent on my queernessâto talk about âmy trans boyfriend,â or âmy boyfriend, whoâs trans,â or whatever other cumbersome construction I could invent.
I find myself avoiding mentioning him to people who donât know the whole story, simply because I donât know what to call him. I speak cryptically to avoid choosing a title. Once I begged off drinks with my coworkers because I was âmeeting someone.â It was fine the first time I said it, but it sounded more and more evasive as I had to repeat it. Who was this âsomeone,â my colleaguesâ looks demanded, and why was I being so fishy about him or her?
Privately, as youâve probably gathered, heâs my âperson,â and Iâm his. The word feels goodâmalleable, comfortable. I use it here because I have the rare opportunity to explain myself. Would it were so simple with the rest of the world. Think thereâs a chance in hell I can introduce the term casually, like itâs already in circulation and youâre just not hip enough to have heard it yet? I fear this could only end like âfetch,â with Regina George screaming at me, âStop trying to make âpersonâ happen! Itâs not going to happen!â
So, what do you think?
First time here? See what we're all about... Get involved... Send us a tip!...