Defeat in Maine: A Volunteer Reflects
This post was submitted by Nathan Tabak. 
We lost despite having a significant fundraising advantage over our opponents. We lost despite turnout that far exceeded most expectations—something which the conventional wisdom held would be a huge boon for our side. We lost despite campaigning in a liberal state—one that, on the same day, overwhelmingly approved a referendum allowing medical marijuana. And, most heartbreakingly for me, despite all the hard work that countless people put into the campaign.
I was one of them. As I’ve previously written, in October I traveled from Washington, DC to Portland as part of the Volunteer Vacation program. After arriving, I was stationed near Bangor for about a week, where I engaged in intensive volunteer recruitment, phonebanking, and canvassing. And during that time, I got a sense of what the No on 1 campaign was about.
It was about the straight, middle-aged volunteer I met on my first day in Portland, who choked up audibly when he described his daughter’s eloquent defense of marriage equality in words borrowed from Walt Whitman.
It was about the pair of activists I met from California, who told me about how they responded with tears and outrage last November after the passage of Proposition 8, and who came to Maine to prevent a redux of that hateful and reprehensible amendment.
It was about the straight boy who led his campus’ No on 1 effort, leading canvassing session after canvassing session and phonebank after phonebank out of his sense of social justice.
But we lost. And in the end, the compassion shown by so many of my straight allies on the campaign, and by many of the Mainers whom I met while recruiting or canvassing, proved to be tragically unrepresentative of the state as a whole.
Maybe, after the twin successes of Proposition 8 and Question 1, it’s fair to conclude that the ballot box is a dead end for marriage equality for now—that the tyranny of the majority will crush us in any state where a marriage referendum can be put on the ballot. Perhaps we ought to focus solely on the courts, and on achieving a federal-level solution there, or on getting Congress to repeal the Defense of Marriage Act.
But while we debate political strategy in the wake of our defeats, one thing is clear: Victory for same-sex marriage is inevitable. Younger voters, according to most polls and in nearly every recent election, back marriage equality in far greater numbers than their parents. Society is slowly turning in the direction of equality. On the same night that Question 1 passed, Washington voters approved an “everything but marriage” domestic partnership law whose passage would have been unthinkable only ten or fifteen years ago.
Equality is the future, and we get closer to it with every passing day. Its face is that of the 17-year-old high school senior who flew in from Colorado to work with us, and the 9-year-old boy who did multiple phonebanking shifts in the local campaign office. They represent everything we’re fighting for, and I’ll never lose sight of that fact—and I don’t think any of my fellow No on 1 volunteers will, either.

I keep hearing that victory is inevitable in the future because of this expected support from tomorrow’s voters. But what if all these wonderful open-minded youth change their minds for some reason or another, or stop voting? It’s a possibility. In the end The Gay may still have to depend on the good graces of other people, and I’m not content with that. I think the only salvation for the gay marriage issue may be through the judicial process. There will always be a bunch of a-holes who oppose this idea, and against gays in general, that I think it will have to come down to a supreme court ruling. Until then it’s going to be a series of humiliating votes against us by a hostile or uncaring majority.
I don’t think the majority of those voters or uncaring. Ignorant, yes, but not uncaring. I think they need education, and its up to us gays to do that. We are the ones most affected by it, and I’d figure that we’d therefore care more about it, as well. Nathan volunteered, but how many of us did? A lot of us were saddened by the vote, but if we didn’t do anything to help it pass then we have less room to be upset.
Personally, I think we need to do more. Talking with and sharing our experiences with those 53% of voters, and the other opponents, in an open, honest discussion is what needs to happen. Thinking about it, if we had a 10% success rate of enlightening our opponents, we’d actually win.
There’s an obvious problem in relying on the majority to guarantee the rights of a minority. On the other hand, it’s also problematic in a democracy to try to impose change from above. Here is my take on strategy:
http://daisybrain.wordpress.com/2009/11/04/seme-sex-marriage-the-maine-event/
Leave your response!
What is TNG?
Find TNG Online
Subscribe to TNG Emails
Follow Rohan at SXSW
More...
- Cute puppy pic!Cute puppy pic!
[No Comments]
- Top 10 Anti-Gay Activists Caught Being…Top 10 Anti-Gay Activists Caught Being Gay
[No Comments]
- Ke$ha ParodyKe$ha Parody
[One Comment]
- Glee+Easter Eggs=AwesomeGlee+Easter Eggs=Awesome
[No Comments]
- Urban Legends!Urban Legends!
[No Comments]
- Shh! Glenn can hear you.Shh! Glenn can hear you.
[No Comments]
- DC Trans Coalition: Today! DCTC…DC Trans Coalition: Today! DCTC testifying before the DC Council about the DC jails
[No Comments]
- Ask me!Ask me!
[No Comments]
- That’s Gay! Awards ShowsThat’s Gay! Awards Shows
[No Comments]
- Granny DJ Rocks ParisGranny DJ Rocks Paris
[No Comments]
More in Chatterbox...Recent Coments
Most Viewed
Most Commented